Collaboration par excellence

Example: Hasselt City Hall, Belgium — The building of the new municipal administration center in Hasselt, Belgium, demonstrates how seamless collaboration in building projects can minimize risks and save costs from the design phase all the way to commissioning.
A joint project of several brands of the Nemetschek Group.
Nemetschek brands involved: Allplan, GRAPHISOFT, Solibri

Pioneering planning and project execution with Open BIM

“The end-to-end use of BIM solutions constitutes genuine added value for all stakeholders in the building process
because it enables seamless and efficient collboration”

Steven Hendrickx, Head Architect in Hasselt

Large-scale, highly complex building projects in particular require ongoing, reliable and efficient coodination between all stakeholders – both internal and external – across disciplines and between companies. Therefore, in association with other market players, the Nemetschek Group is promoting the Open BIM data standard. This is a universal, collaborative approach to designing, constructing and operating buildings based on open standards and workflows It makes it possible for project stakeholders to collaborate, even if the type of software varies from user to user. The Industry Foundation Classes (IFC) interface has established itself as an open standard and is therefore of central significance.

Sharing and evaluating data throughout the entire product life cycle saves time and money and improves quality. The administration of data is key to this digital transformation, for it is only possible to take full advantage of the potential if each stakeholder can access the data that he or she needs at any given time. This begins with a realistic BIM building model, which is an essential prerequisite for a genuine 5D workflo. This model is no longer limited to just 3D construction data; it also includes data concerning the dimensions of time and costs.

Seamless collaboration exemplified by the Hasselt City Hall

Under the management of the architect team comprising Jaspers-Eyers, MASS Architects and Michel Janssen, a new municipal administration center is being built in Hasselt. The complex, consisting of a renovated building section and a new building, provides approx. 17,000 m2 for the city administration and social services as well as offices. The architects and their most important partners are using Open BIM software solutions for the entire construction process. Three Nemetschek solutions are being implemented for this project: Archicad from Graphisoft for the design and planning of the architects, Allplan Engineering for civil engineering, and the Solibri Model Checker for the BIM quality control carried out by the construction company.

From the beginning, all information concerning the building project is contained in the digital building model – from the draft to implementation – including all design details, desired materials, fire protection requirements, acoustic properties, insulation and building structures, and administration. This constitutes considerable added value for all stakeholders compared to the old standard model, which was purely 3D. Thus, this improvement ensures more than just seamless collaboration between all those involved. The complex project can be turned over to the municipality – the proud building owner – with the required quality, on time and within the specified budget.

Hasselt City Hall is groundbreaking – in terms of design, planning and project implementation.

Independent and yet consistent

Steven Hendrickx, the head architect in Hasselt, recognized four decisive factors with Open BIM over the course of the successful project:

  • Individual partners design their model with their preferred BIM software, and with their own templates. Outstanding collaboration is ensured, though, thanks to a common, uniform standard which is specified in advance.
  • The division of labor is defined at the beginning of the project. Data on statics, for instance, have an essential impact on the architecture and structural design. Data on heating, ventilation and air-conditioning, on the other hand, are also important but don’t generally flow directly into the architecture. These data, for example, can be sufficiently analyzed with the BIM solution for quality assurance from Solibri.
  • Design changes in one area don’t necessarily affect the plans of all the others involved in the project. The architecture and the building stage are inherently the most closely linked.
  • The expertise of the staff, i.e., extensive holistic knowledge of the various building disciplines, is also critical for the success of the project.

Two examples of the advantage of precise planning

In Hasselt, the construction company was commissioned with excavation, among other tasks. An assessment of the amount of sand that needed to be removed was done based on a cal culation using conventional 2D planning methods, which yielded a result of 800 cubic meters. The engineers used the Solibri Model Checker based on Open BIM and the data provided by the architects and arrived at a figue that was just half this amount, i.e., 400 cubic meters of sand. This shows how exact the work with Open BIM solutions can be.

The steel struts to be installed are another example: With the interface function IFC Exports from Allplan, it was possible to use the BIM model to automatically calculate which steel struts needed fieproofing. All it took was a mouse click to obtain precise results, right down to the running meter. In projects that don’t use Open BIM solutions, these calculations are made by manually entering the data from 2D drawings in Excel or some other software and then recalculating and evaluating the data for use in quotations and planning, a process that is susceptible to error and one that leaves a lot of room for interpretation. These errors often go undetected until the actual cost planning is already completed. In the case of the Hasselt City Hall,  it was possible to avoid such errors from the outset.

Converting to Open BIM pays off

As is the case with any change, it takes a certain amount of time for companies and employees to accept BIM as the norm. The best way, according to Steven Hendrickx, is to start out by planning smaller projects using BIM. The experience thereby gained will make it possible to complete successively larger BIM projects. The advantages of collaborating through Open BIM are obvious: The entire workflow is much simpler for all project stakeholders, and building projects are completed within time and cost budgets.

CONCLUSION

Consistent standards and open interfaces in par-ticular are essential for successful building projects. Stakeholders need solutions that can “work together” for all and any individual tasks being performed. Seamless collaboration between humans and machines: This is ensured with Open BIM, and backed by the brands of the Nemetschek Group.



Reference projects on this topic:

When the building needs to remain operational

Cidade Mall, located in the centre of Belo Horizonte, has gone through three expansions since 1991. This year it will undergo a complete retrofit including aesthetic changes. All facilities inside the building will also be modernized. In total there are six floors of shopping area resulting in 62,400 m² of built surface on a plot of 7,500 m².



 

Nemetschek brand involved: Data Design System

The different jobs are carried out in several stages, whilst it is not acceptable to close down the mall and refuse access to the 80,000 daily visitors. Since the start, which was approximately eight years ago, a number of jobs have been successfully completed including a complete upgrade of the electrical installations. The air-conditioning system conversion to CCW (central chilled water) is about to be completed.

Necessary changes

The mechanical design is aimed at the revitalization of existing facilities, which include: a CCW air conditioning system existing of two chillers with centrifugal compressors, low noise cooling towers, a set of primary and secondary pumps for the cooling water circuits, and a set of pumps for the condensation circuit.

The director of Climatizar Engenharia, Francisco Pimenta, says that with the optimization and increased reliability of the air conditioning system, one CCW was designed with three chillers, with a compressor type "Bolt" offering high efficiency and a unit capacity of 550 TR. The same applies to the cooling towers, however, these cover the exchange of all pumps for the in-line type and frequency inverters - "It contributes significantly to the perfect fit of the water flows and savings in energy consumption," says Pimenta.

In full operation

As the mall has to remain operational, it was essential for the systems to continue functioning properly. "The bottom line was to redesign the complete CCW unit without making it stop working. That alone made this job very unusual and brought along additional complexity," as stated by Pimenta.
The execution of this job is taking place primarily at night, in very detailed defined steps. For example, there are several steps of interconnecting new pipes with existing ones and moving in new bulky equipment to replace the existing equipment.

The advantage of BIM models

One of the great contributions of BIM to the designers was the complete overview of the existing situation and the viability of proposed design changes from the beginning up to the completion of the job. As this was a retrofit, it would have been very difficult to implement a design using only floor plans and cross sections coming from traditional CAD drawings. "We had to consider existing pipe routes and reuse them. Furthermore, we had to make bypasses at strategic locations. It was easy to visualize the possible solutions, which was a great benefit to us", says Pimenta.
Another advantage is not directly linked to the design process. Whilst, with the BIM model, the engineers could show the client the existing situation and take them through all design stages using 3D visualizations. "We even created an animation showing the complete CCW unit in the technical room", says Pimenta. This was crucial to the understanding of the solutions presented to the client.

How was the BIM software choice made?

The designers of Climatizar Engenharia adopted DDS-CAD for just over one year, and this is the only BIM software they use. "What led us to use DDS-CAD was especially the ease of use and its intuitiveness of designing MEP systems", says Pimenta.
An additional advantage of the software is that, compared to other BIM software, DDS-CAD is much lighter and runs smoothly on standard hardware. Furthermore, as Pimenta indicates, "DDS-CAD is not an architectural tool with some MEP features on top of it. The software is specifically tailored to MEP engineering and supports the processes that we engineers apply in a BIM workflow".

DDS-CAD in Brazil

Together with other pioneering companies in Brazil, Climatizar Engenharia is closely working together with Data Design System to further localize the software. "As always with new software, we faced some challenges at the beginning. But Pimenta stresses the major gains that are achieved in the design process. If there is a conflict, for example, between two ducts, DDS-CAD instantly solves it. This significantly improves the quality of our designs.

"The urge to change from using CAD drawings to BIM models in projects is evident in our market. The delivery time for projects decreases each year and the need to have reliable and consistent output becomes more and more important", explains Pimenta. For this reason, even if the change in the way of working requires "courage and patience", as he himself points out, "we have to leave our comfort zone and embrace new innovations."
The advantages seem clear to the designers, Pimenta reflects on the use of BIM models at the construction sites. "Today, there are not many professionals who know how to use the BIM information correctly, I believe this is a point that will take longer." But Pimenta stresses that the gains for construction companies are huge, because of the richness of data inside a BIM model. "They only have to understand and experience how they can effectively make use of it."